Cultivating a close feeling of friendship and fellowship among the Professional Fire Fighters in the State of Rhode Island… read more

Comments Box SVG iconsUsed for the like, share, comment, and reaction icons
This message is only visible to admins.
Problem displaying Facebook posts. Backup cache in use.
Error: Error validating access token: The user has not authorized application 1332798716823516.
Type: OAuthException

RISAFF proudly hosted our annual legislative dinner in Washington DC. We appreciate the attendance and continued unwavering support from Senator Jack Reed, Senator Sheldon Whitehouse, Representative James Langevin and Representative David Cicilline.

Thank you to IAFF Edward A. Kelly IAFF General President , Frank Lima - IAFF GST, IAFF District 3 VP Jay Colbert and the many other staff and support personnel from the IAFF who joined us, as well as the leadership from our other 3rd district IAFF State Associations.

Thank you to all our RISAFF locals and members made this year’s legislative dinner our highest attended yet, we appreciate all members who took the time to attend.
... See MoreSee Less

RISAFF proudly hosted our annual legislative dinner in Washington DC. We appreciate the attendance and continued unwavering support from Senator Jack Reed, Senator Sheldon Whitehouse, Representative James Langevin and Representative David Cicilline. 

Thank you to IAFF Edward A. Kelly IAFF General President , Frank Lima -  IAFF GST,  IAFF District 3 VP Jay Colbert and the many other staff and support personnel from the IAFF who joined us, as well as the leadership from our other 3rd district IAFF State Associations. 

Thank you to all our RISAFF locals and members made this year’s legislative dinner our highest attended yet, we appreciate all members who took the time to attend.Image attachmentImage attachment+Image attachment

Our thoughts and prayers are with the brothers and sisters of Baltimore Fire Fighters Local 734.🔥WORKING DWELLING FIRE🔥
200 blk S Stricker St 21223
#NewSouthwestMountClare
Council District 9 Councilman John Bullock

557a #BMORESBravest arrived with fire showing from all 3 floors of a 3 story row home. Additional units called.

630a #BMORESBravest fighting fire in several 3 story row homes. There has been a collapse and multiple mayday calls were made by trapped firefighters. #BCFDSOC Special Rescue Team is on scene.

715a 3 of #BMORESBravest were trapped in the collapse; 1 has been rescued & #BCFDEMS is taking to Shock Trauma in serious condition. #BCFDSOC Special Rescue Team continues to work on freeing the other 2

740a 1 more #BMORESBravest has been rescued by #BCFDSOC Special Rescue Team. #BCFDEMS to treat & transport. Condition serious. 1 member remains trapped, crews are in contact & are working to free them.

825a another #BMORESBravest freed from the building. #BCFDEMS treating & transporting to Shock Trauma, condition unk. Rich Langford Baltimore Firefighters Local 734 President is at hospital to supporting our members & their families.

1030a There is no update on this incident at this time. Baltimore City Fire Department will provide information to the media when there is an update on conditions.

12p #RumorControl
3 of #BMORESBravest were transported to Shock Trauma in serious condition.
1 remains trapped inside the house.
Anything else is rumor.
BCFD will brief media at Shock Trauma when they have an u/d.

2p There is still no update from BCFD.
Last information we have is:
1 FF still trapped in the collapsed home
3 FFs transported to Shock Trauma in serious condition. These are the facts.
... See MoreSee Less

Our thoughts and prayers are with the brothers and sisters of Baltimore Fire Fighters Local 734.

Thank you RI State Representative Julie Casimiro for your continued efforts to support Fire Fighters in Rhode Island and bringing awareness to Fire Fighters who are battling cancer.
We appreciate your recognition of brother Joe Hartman , North Kingstown Local 1651 and supporting his fight.
... See MoreSee Less

Thank you RI State Representative Julie Casimiro for your continued efforts to support Fire Fighters in Rhode Island and bringing awareness to Fire Fighters who are battling cancer. 
We appreciate your recognition of brother Joe Hartman , North Kingstown Local 1651 and supporting his fight.Image attachmentImage attachment

Our thoughts and prayers are with the family of Captain Thomas L. Geremia Jr. and our brothers and sisters of Providence Fire Fighters Local 799. ... See MoreSee Less

Our thoughts and prayers are with the family of Captain Thomas L. Geremia Jr. and our brothers and sisters of Providence Fire Fighters Local 799.

Firefighters counter arbitration criticism leveled by panel

Posted

In an interview following an article that covered the Rhode Island League of Cities and Town’s panel discussion of the state’s binding arbitration process, the state firefighters union has responded strongly to criticisms levied against it, which they claim were unfair and disingenuous.

“To some degree, what the attorneys said didn’t surprise me, because I view them as they were salesmen. They were there at that forum to get themselves hired,” said Joseph A. Andriole, president of the Rhode Island State Association of Firefighters. “If they truly, at that forum, wanted to be objective and look at the process, they would have had a balance on that panel.”

Andriole is referring to the three-person panel that spoke during a breakout session at the 18th Annual Convention of the Rhode Island League of Cities and Towns at the Crowne Plaza in Warwick on Jan. 25.

The panel consisted of Vincent Ragosta Jr., Timothy Bliss, both attorneys who have been involved in arbitration negotiations between Rhode Island municipalities and labor organizations. The third panelist, Vijay Kappor, was also an attorney with a financial background who gave a presentation on how municipal leaders can better prepare better financial presentations for arbitration sessions to achieve a more desirable outcome.

The panelists spared no criticism of the arbitration process, and Ragosta was particularly critical of both the process itself, saying it should “be avoided at all costs,” and of fire unions as well, referring to the International Association of Firefighters (the national union that encompasses the state fire union and all the local municipality unions) as a “virtual cartel.”

“I find that word very divisive,” Andriole said. “I can see that maybe he’s frustrated because maybe he’s unhappy with his own work product or the results that he’s getting, but to say something derogatory about your counterpart on the other side, I think was very disingenuous and truly beneath him.”

Ragosta said that the arbitration process was flawed due to a few reasons, including how unions will regularly bring up arbitration decisions from way back when the process was first initiated in 1961 to argue their case, no matter what the current municipality’s situation.

Additionally, Ragosta and Bliss agreed that unions will often put forward multiple, sometimes as many as a dozen, different proposals for negotiations – only to drop the majority of them after the municipal side has spent time preparing rebuttals for those proposals; in essence to waste time and money and drag out the process.

Andriole argued that such tactics were not limited to labor unions, and that arbitrators are mutually chosen and agreed upon by either side during an arbitration process (barring an administrative appointment when neither side can agree to one person), so getting a more positive or negative outcome through arbitration comes down simply to preparing a better case.

“I think it’s important for both sides to have that [tactic available to them]. The cities and towns have that same ability,” he said. “All of the data we use is all public record. There is no magic wand here that makes us win the case. What makes us win the case is we put on strong cases that have strong merit behind them, and the other side does not.”

Andriole estimated, stemming from his nearly 30 years of experience in labor negotiations, that only 10 percent of labor disputes must resort to the arbitration process. He argued that, while the panel said that unions use the arbitration process as leverage to gain themselves a better outcome, municipalities could be accused of that same charge.

“In my opinion, the cities and towns use the threat of going to arbitration as leverage,” he said. “I’ve seen cities and towns threaten arbitration to try to get a better deal and leverage the union into a compromise that is more suited for the city or the town. I have seen them use arbitration as a way to, for a lack of a better term, to shake the tree and get some people to retire.”

Another criticism levied by the panel of attorneys was that unions utilize members during arbitration who aren’t trained in legal matters during the process, which creates difficulties when dealing with the complex legal and financial issues that arise during a collective bargaining negotiation.

Andriole countered that by saying that it is a relatively recent development that municipalities have utilized outside counsel to handle labor negotiations, and that doing so costs more tax dollars – he estimated in the range of $100,000 or more for each contract – and results in a muddying and complication of the process that used to be primarily handled in-house.

“I think we use laypeople to, A; control the cost, and I think we use laypeople because our people are passionate and know our subject matter,” he said. “So I would suggest to the cities and towns that, maybe if they got their fire chiefs more involved in the process, and their mayors more involved in the process or their city solicitors more involved, going to outside counsel is, to me, just throwing taxpayer money out the window.”

In response to Johnston Mayor Joseph Polisena, who suggested during the Jan. 25 panel discussion that arbitrators should be limited to only retired Rhode Island judges, magistrates or attorneys, Andriole said that this would be like a municipality limiting themselves to hiring a city solicitor who is from that city or town – rather than choosing the most qualified person for the job.

“My argument would be that maybe they need to be hired by cities and towns based on their experience,” he said. “I like to go in front of an arbitrator that neither side knows, that are picked on their neutrality, their credentials and their qualifications – versus someone that we personally know or maybe the cities or towns have a personal relationship with.”

In summation, Andriole said that the process does not favor either side. He believes it is a neutral process that is necessary to bring both sides to an agreement, for better or worse. He also said it is an important part of the bargaining process in Rhode Island since public safety departments cannot legally strike.

“I don’t think that the process is a problem,” he said. “I think that the other side doesn’t like some of the results that they’re getting – but that’s because they’re not putting on good cases.”

Click here to add your own text